Amy J. Ko on Nostr: npub19d9p0…kf02p You're right to probe into what the criteria for a good review ...

npub19d9p04u4xfysdy92fycw947jrca3xve2gnsauysshzewxvmz8dms6kf02p (npub19d9…f02p) You're right to probe into what the criteria for a good review are. That's a healthy discussion we can't have now, because there's no accountability in reviewing to motivate it. I'm excited to help run the community discussion in our field to shape it, and to craft accountability mechanisms for editors.

Re: power, I'm not sure what alternative you're proposing. Eliminate editorial boards, editors? I'd love to hear concrete ideas, and how they'd result in better peer review.