ancaprevolt on Nostr: That would be a circular definition. I gave the definition of man, which is adult ...

That would be a circular definition. I gave the definition of man, which is adult human male. You cannot identify as a male, because what exactly are you identifying as? A male is described as an individual who produces small gametes (sperm) naturally.

So of course I would not accept the definition of man being “anyone who identifies as male”. You cannot identify as someone who produces small gametes if you do not produce small gametes.

By definition, trans women are men. They are adult human males. They cannot in any way be construed as females, and therefore, they cannot be women.