Redish Lab on Nostr: #Cosyne needs to decide if it is a journal or a conference. š”ā They ask for ...
#Cosyne needs to decide if it is a journal or a conference. š”ā They ask for 2-page "abstracts", but then review the 2 pages as if they are a full paper. 2/3 reviews we got back included statements of "I don't understand why they didn't do X", where X was (a) Figure 5 of a 10-page paper ("abstract" included figure 1-3) or (b) a 3-year $500k project beyond the actual submission. The one good review was for a project that could be completely described in 2 pages. That's not an abstract.
Published at
2024-01-18 18:24:39Event JSON
{
"id": "c5914143c54851e07c75e83e8b9171163994efacd1a66596d469cb507651cb24",
"pubkey": "cfa5d6820d238da7e6c2aed51db7da764c709fe6e0014d466193aca904c7b602",
"created_at": 1705602279,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"t",
"cosyne"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://neuromatch.social/users/adredish/statuses/111778350985198311",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "#Cosyne needs to decide if it is a journal or a conference. š”ā They ask for 2-page \"abstracts\", but then review the 2 pages as if they are a full paper. 2/3 reviews we got back included statements of \"I don't understand why they didn't do X\", where X was (a) Figure 5 of a 10-page paper (\"abstract\" included figure 1-3) or (b) a 3-year $500k project beyond the actual submission. The one good review was for a project that could be completely described in 2 pages. That's not an abstract.",
"sig": "c740f6f426aeae0fcab6b367f026c4438e21df65469c7a9561cd5fe676bf37fe586a05ac8aab3c88c83f15f5f2540ded5faeebc0a3453fcbb1dcf23b6dc8cae7"
}
