waxwing on Nostr: Good point to compare with a platform. What I'm really saying is just that: yes, a ...
Good point to compare with a platform. What I'm really saying is just that: yes, a set of (changing occasionally) relays is clearly superior in cens. res. over a single corporate platform, but it's not really enough; say there are 4 really popular relays, a censor attacking them is enough to make nostr not work very well. Even maybe 10 instead of 4, you could imagine it being effective. *Killing* a protocol like nostr, totally, is not viable - it's for sure decentralized enough to stay alive. But I'm saying that in practice it can be heavily damaged if relays are all clearnet and/or the operators are threatenable.
(And it's worse, arguably: if you can convince several "main" relay operators to block an account or message, you might be able to convince basically all of them, under some variant of public pressure. Only a fully anonymous operator is immune to that pressure. But I admit that at this point, I'm setting the bar a bit too high!)
Published at
2025-04-24 14:30:51Event JSON
{
"id": "0ed9016d4d99ddfa81c6f052cb3ada759f72c90ea3733c8a35b21910d3f73f51",
"pubkey": "675b84fe75e216ab947c7438ee519ca7775376ddf05dadfba6278bd012e1d728",
"created_at": 1745505051,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"e2902eaef6404a5b95f5c6743a2e0ed6d0f8ecf3c9c9c86a5169ce44014d7b1e",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"c0bff0b975502aabbfb5d069c776653400d1a4a96f615265b2bd6da6bdabdf18"
],
[
"e",
"ce29c71c08f9a2226de924725e509c5a7418316fc5145cda12570ea960ec5dd6",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"675b84fe75e216ab947c7438ee519ca7775376ddf05dadfba6278bd012e1d728"
],
[
"p",
"df478ecdffe91db90469aeced8d5a33efcaaf75231bb4d768e711184495107a7"
]
],
"content": "Good point to compare with a platform. What I'm really saying is just that: yes, a set of (changing occasionally) relays is clearly superior in cens. res. over a single corporate platform, but it's not really enough; say there are 4 really popular relays, a censor attacking them is enough to make nostr not work very well. Even maybe 10 instead of 4, you could imagine it being effective. *Killing* a protocol like nostr, totally, is not viable - it's for sure decentralized enough to stay alive. But I'm saying that in practice it can be heavily damaged if relays are all clearnet and/or the operators are threatenable.\n\n(And it's worse, arguably: if you can convince several \"main\" relay operators to block an account or message, you might be able to convince basically all of them, under some variant of public pressure. Only a fully anonymous operator is immune to that pressure. But I admit that at this point, I'm setting the bar a bit too high!)",
"sig": "83b4fe384ba7871dc846b175f95569b5359a5543352d5f87e2470a4403ff160f141b65e976e5875d058cb35ce461435de8f68bfc5524cb0843c78f34148dfac5"
}
