matt on Nostr: They’re really not, though. Also important to point out that you can’t “just” ...

They’re really not, though. Also important to point out that you can’t “just” withdraw all your tokens piecemeal as the fee to do that (even over lightning) would dominate, and the intermediate hoops through the lightning network plus withdraw steps would almost certainly be a unique fingerprint. I’m quite confident you’d end up with zero additional privacy against a pool that really dug into it.

quoting nevent1q…f2cn

I totally understand your argument here but you didn’t address any of my points - (a) this isn’t actually practical because no one would use such a pool, (b) this doesn’t solve the IP-level privacy issues (which are the biggest issues for privacy on a pool by farrrrr!), (c) this doesn’t actually improve payout privacy since there’s a privacy loss when the user goes to (bulk) withdraw (basically the privacy ends up being the same as just doing lightning withdraws from the pool!)