nielliesmons on Nostr: Yes, it's similar. Important differences: 1) NIP-72 didn't have chat, lol š, which ...
Yes, it's similar.
Important differences:
1) NIP-72 didn't have chat, lol š, which would have made it a ton more active from the start
2) it still forces creators into the false choice of publishing in one niche vs in the fEeD. And besides chat, they'll almost always choose the feed
3) in the way apps handled it ONLY the root posts were somewhat constrained to the community
4) you can't edit that a-tag away later (or add other communities that fit your target audience)
5) active approval is required. The signing of an event by a moderator, and the delay that comes with that, is a huge barrier.
6) there was no interop between relays and this spec, so admins could not just piut a relay behind their community that followed the moderation/price lists they defined in the Kind:34550 community definition
I'm still not sure if the community needs its own keypair or whether just defining moderators is fine.
Important differences:
1) NIP-72 didn't have chat, lol š, which would have made it a ton more active from the start
2) it still forces creators into the false choice of publishing in one niche vs in the fEeD. And besides chat, they'll almost always choose the feed
3) in the way apps handled it ONLY the root posts were somewhat constrained to the community
4) you can't edit that a-tag away later (or add other communities that fit your target audience)
5) active approval is required. The signing of an event by a moderator, and the delay that comes with that, is a huge barrier.
6) there was no interop between relays and this spec, so admins could not just piut a relay behind their community that followed the moderation/price lists they defined in the Kind:34550 community definition
I'm still not sure if the community needs its own keypair or whether just defining moderators is fine.