Luke Dashjr [ARCHIVE] on Nostr: 📅 Original date posted:2016-01-26 📝 Original message:On Tuesday, January 26, ...
📅 Original date posted:2016-01-26
📝 Original message:On Tuesday, January 26, 2016 2:54:16 AM Toby Padilla wrote:
> Luke - As stated in the Github thread, I totally understand where you're
> coming from but the fact is people *will* encode data on the blockchain
> using worse methods. For all of the reasons that OP_RETURN was a good idea
> in the first place, it's a good idea to support it in PaymentRequests.
As I explained, none of those reasons apply to PaymentRequests.
> As for keyless - there's no way (that I know of) to construct a transaction
> with a zero value OP_RETURN in an environment without keys since the
> Payment Protocol is what defines the method for getting a transaction from
> a server to a wallet. You can make a custom transaction and execute it in
> the same application but without Payments there's no way to move
> transactions between two applications. You need to build the transaction
> where you execute it and thus need a key.
I have no idea what you are trying to say here.
Luke
📝 Original message:On Tuesday, January 26, 2016 2:54:16 AM Toby Padilla wrote:
> Luke - As stated in the Github thread, I totally understand where you're
> coming from but the fact is people *will* encode data on the blockchain
> using worse methods. For all of the reasons that OP_RETURN was a good idea
> in the first place, it's a good idea to support it in PaymentRequests.
As I explained, none of those reasons apply to PaymentRequests.
> As for keyless - there's no way (that I know of) to construct a transaction
> with a zero value OP_RETURN in an environment without keys since the
> Payment Protocol is what defines the method for getting a transaction from
> a server to a wallet. You can make a custom transaction and execute it in
> the same application but without Payments there's no way to move
> transactions between two applications. You need to build the transaction
> where you execute it and thus need a key.
I have no idea what you are trying to say here.
Luke