Scoundrel on Nostr: The outbox model is great for user based note aggregation, but it is absolutely ...
The outbox model is great for user based note aggregation, but it is absolutely useless for topic based note aggregation. Personally, I very rarely care what users my notes come from. What I care about is what topics the notes are about. I believe that being able to use relays with your values and relays supporting notes on a given topic is far more important than being able to find a relay that supports notes from a user you like.
I wouldn't count on "[N]otes and [O]ther [ST]uff over [R]elays" to transmit notes in other ways. I believe the direction Nostr needs to go is toward relay auditing and transparency. Unfortunately I haven't heard anyone else advocating for this. I don't believe that self sovereignty advocates on Nostr fully understand the assignment here.
Published at
2025-04-20 21:42:57Event JSON
{
"id": "d7b7958e32ad32ecf33ab93dd63b6a146df58e7c5b9d587d2aa9671c43cf823e",
"pubkey": "a87b402ac081c8849b9d5bd4e39f2287f25709d3e3f79e784af1e8b38fefbdf1",
"created_at": 1745185377,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"67312f07ddaeda507501447efa74f538d0fe7ea2f11876a69dc9914ffb5862e5",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"59160299e2cd3fef7f9a6e6974765bec60bb0444a0ae0ddd968b5e7c88304c3d"
],
[
"e",
"84e9b99ee0d3b2906ca830986385abbbe40b6cd9164124079fa3cd0962b4ac1d",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"9ca0bd7450742d6a20319c0e3d4c679c9e046a9dc70e8ef55c2905e24052340b"
],
[
"p",
"a87b402ac081c8849b9d5bd4e39f2287f25709d3e3f79e784af1e8b38fefbdf1"
],
[
"p",
"deab79dafa1c2be4b4a6d3aca1357b6caa0b744bf46ad529a5ae464288579e68"
]
],
"content": "The outbox model is great for user based note aggregation, but it is absolutely useless for topic based note aggregation. Personally, I very rarely care what users my notes come from. What I care about is what topics the notes are about. I believe that being able to use relays with your values and relays supporting notes on a given topic is far more important than being able to find a relay that supports notes from a user you like.\n\nI wouldn't count on \"[N]otes and [O]ther [ST]uff over [R]elays\" to transmit notes in other ways. I believe the direction Nostr needs to go is toward relay auditing and transparency. Unfortunately I haven't heard anyone else advocating for this. I don't believe that self sovereignty advocates on Nostr fully understand the assignment here.",
"sig": "b413649ee06db01c72e7e9eab966acfefce4e9b1de51bc6044f55c22211c51efa0f1d972b93b3746344f675356ecfb9355a565d1fd77fa004dccd6ac6a4c7e0a"
}