matt13black on Nostr: How do we scale Nostr? “Unpopular opinion: Nostr CAN'T scale to be what people want ...
How do we scale Nostr?
“Unpopular opinion: Nostr CAN'T scale to be what people want it to be. It's an all-to-all broadcast, which scales like O(n²). It will collapse in its own success.
Nostr relays are like sidechains and altcoins. It's attempting to solve an O(n²) scaling problem by having multiple copies of the same thing. It leads to Balkanization where you can't see content from or message some people.
Blockchains of blockchains were dumb and this is dumb in exactly the same way, and I can't believe all of you failed your algorithms classes.”
- Bob McElrath
So this begs the question, how does Nostr scale long term? Or do we simply expect 2 of 3 dominant relays in the long term?
cc fiatjaf (npub180c…h6w6) jb55 (npub1xts…kk5s) Derek Ross (npub18am…p424) AsaiToshiya (npub1pgh…rs38) Vitor Pamplona (npub1gcx…nj5z) sepehr (npub18c5…0we7)
https://x.com/bobmcelrath/status/1828763959001804956
“Unpopular opinion: Nostr CAN'T scale to be what people want it to be. It's an all-to-all broadcast, which scales like O(n²). It will collapse in its own success.
Nostr relays are like sidechains and altcoins. It's attempting to solve an O(n²) scaling problem by having multiple copies of the same thing. It leads to Balkanization where you can't see content from or message some people.
Blockchains of blockchains were dumb and this is dumb in exactly the same way, and I can't believe all of you failed your algorithms classes.”
- Bob McElrath
So this begs the question, how does Nostr scale long term? Or do we simply expect 2 of 3 dominant relays in the long term?
cc fiatjaf (npub180c…h6w6) jb55 (npub1xts…kk5s) Derek Ross (npub18am…p424) AsaiToshiya (npub1pgh…rs38) Vitor Pamplona (npub1gcx…nj5z) sepehr (npub18c5…0we7)
https://x.com/bobmcelrath/status/1828763959001804956