Dr. Victoria Grinberg on Nostr: I have a simple but to some folks still surprising hack for dealing with peer review ...
I have a simple but to some folks still surprising hack for dealing with peer review reports: every time you write a longer explanation as a reply to the reviewer, it should go into the text of the paper. If a reviewer did not understand or misunderstood it, some other reader will have the same problem, too.
Took me a while to get here. Mainly multiple cases of telling authors whose reviewer I was to just add what they wrote to me to the actual paper ...
#astrodon #AcademicChatter
Published at
2024-10-11 16:26:39Event JSON
{
"id": "7382fd72cc393ff2292c1b0e8796e9b98d401776f50a6828a3eba20ec4b43132",
"pubkey": "44ce4bcf042337e76b9dce4dcce34c003dbd21d8762a4e09caad3a8e3b650579",
"created_at": 1728663999,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"t",
"Astrodon"
],
[
"t",
"academicchatter"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://mastodon.social/users/vicgrinberg/statuses/113289723855533970",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "I have a simple but to some folks still surprising hack for dealing with peer review reports: every time you write a longer explanation as a reply to the reviewer, it should go into the text of the paper. If a reviewer did not understand or misunderstood it, some other reader will have the same problem, too.\n\nTook me a while to get here. Mainly multiple cases of telling authors whose reviewer I was to just add what they wrote to me to the actual paper ...\n\n#astrodon #AcademicChatter",
"sig": "9c73d217b5ddc59130745975dce23a0a1ce8ed01af000b5b025035855412f626fa34b9c59a314d45ce4b9d5a0f50eb38b83507905f035f1fe3a791d416ba8b15"
}
