Tybbs on Nostr: this is an excellent example of an "is-ought" fallacy. your argument addresses the ...
this is an excellent example of an "is-ought" fallacy.
your argument addresses the historical fact of land changing hands by force, it fails to address the moral implications of these actions
just because changes in land ownership have been predicated by violence for most of human history, does not mean they should still be
we must aim to be better
Published at
2025-02-04 20:59:56Event JSON
{
"id": "aacfa50b0645c6c923cf9a386391cff774a70fedb6c9ced0f55cb50e43f0b1bf",
"pubkey": "34a199b925388816138f8953e67b5ec6e323c30f9269403627316b39a84ea18b",
"created_at": 1738702796,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"92784ef7cd3b84cef2846a048c14f16873949e4fe4b8db3d81c50f196c35eb51",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"22d13c34a9fbf0ad1633ad53028c89ccad7ccda879596491d1348cc1216f01a1",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"34a199b925388816138f8953e67b5ec6e323c30f9269403627316b39a84ea18b"
],
[
"p",
"ecf468164bd743b75683db3870ce01cb9a1d4b8ec203ed26de50f96255bbc75a"
]
],
"content": "this is an excellent example of an \"is-ought\" fallacy.\n\nyour argument addresses the historical fact of land changing hands by force, it fails to address the moral implications of these actions \n\njust because changes in land ownership have been predicated by violence for most of human history, does not mean they should still be\n\nwe must aim to be better ",
"sig": "aa7afb1dae4eb05850c7cc7279ee68b640ec3a4551842b656bcd37f358d6b78b420edaa67a0fd6bfe407a48bf23302dfeb8c04344ce428af028fd27889dfcc13"
}
